Peer review Peer review

 The reviewing process involves the following steps: 


  • Receiving the paper in the required format and using the imposed technical instructions for authors. The full paper manuscript will be submitted electronically in Word 2003 format to the:valeriu.ionescu@upit.roemail address whichwill inform the authors that work email arrived in good condition. The papers will be returned to the authors for correction if they don't follow the presented instructions. The journal redaction board reserves the right not to publish the non-corresponding materials.
  • Within maximum 15 days the editors will nominate the reviewers and address the paper manuscript to them; peer reviewing will be accorded to each paper by at least two referees; in cases of uncertainty, the editorial board will discuss the paper and take the final decision upon publication.
  • The referees will use a specific reviewing template; the paper will receive a score and may be recommended for:


0, 1

Reject - poor paper (comments from reviewers are obligatory)


Weak Reject - can be published only if major revisions and improvements are made (comments should included); send the paper to the authors, with comments;


Weak Accept - publish as such or send for improvements and revision (comments should included);


Accept – publish as a good paper;


Accept – publish as an excellent paper; recommendation for best Scientific Bulletin paper


If necessary, the required changes will be transmitted to authors; the changes may be accepted totally or partially by the author(s); in the latter case, the referees' conditions may be challenged by the author(s) and the paper submitted for a second reviewing.
         The date of publishing acceptance will be communicated to author(s) and printed on the published paper. The final print-ready format as requested by the editors has to be transmitted by authors within 30 days from acceptance. The special cases have to be adjusted according to the editors' demands.

The whole responsibility for the papers contents regarding experimental results and their interpretation, accuracy computation as well as language incumbent to the authors only. The authors must respect the Copyright laws.